📌 China’s Q3 GDP and services indicators diverge
China’s GDP grew 4.5% year over year in the third quarter and 1.2% quarter over quarter on a seasonally adjusted basis; meanwhile, services production and retail sales weakened year over year, while the year-over-year growth rate of the tertiary sector reached 5.2%. The aggregate data and indicators for related industries are moving in different directions. This is worth watching, but it is not yet possible to determine on this basis which data, if any, are inaccurate.
The divergence is not limited to retail. Year-over-year services production indices for information, business, finance, and other sectors also declined. ChinaMacroFacts notes that historically, the services production index has had strong explanatory power for the performance of the tertiary sector. Therefore, the weakening of multiple services indicators alongside a rebound in the tertiary sector’s growth rate warrants further verification.
The information currently available provides no links to the underlying data or independent verification, and cannot explain whether the discrepancy stems from statistical definitions, industry composition, or other factors. For readers, the key is not to draw an immediate conclusion about either GDP or services data, but to watch whether subsequent data can explain this opposing movement. Until further verification is available, this divergence is an issue to keep in mind, not evidence that its cause has been established.
▌ Sources